This post may contain affiliate or referral links. Read more about this in our disclosure policy.
Warning! These are VERY addicting and seem to whisper at you from the kitchen counter and seem to jump into your mouth without warning 😉 At least that's what I tell myself when I make them and they disappear in about a day. But really it's just my lack of self-control around sweets. They are a great dessert recipe to have on hand.
Homemade Candy Buckeyes Recipe
If you want to make this recipe even richer you can use milk chocolate chips. Yeah…… been there done that and …. YUM! I have also tried it with chunky peanut butter but really it just wants the same but more power to you if you can make it work.
Related: Copy Cat Thin Mint Cookies Recipe
Line cookie sheet with parchment paper.
Mix together peanut butter, butter, and vanilla.
Gradually add the powdered sugar, stirring it into the mixture until it is incorporated.
Roll into 1-inch balls and place on the prepared sheet.
Insert a toothpick into each ball.
Place in the freezer until hard (about 30 minutes).
Combine the chocolate chips and shortening.
Melt by microwaving for 1 minute, then stirring and repeating until smooth and melted.
Use the toothpick to dip into the chocolate (leave a small circle uncoated on top of each).
Gently shake off excess and place back on sheet.
Refrigerate for several hours until chocolate sets.
Remove toothpicks and smooth over the hole.
Related: 30 Christmas Candy Recipes
Any tips for many Candy Buckeyes that you want to share?